This page evaluates the mechanical suitability of five high-performance cable candidates—Dyneema® SK78 (1mm and 3mm), Dyneema® DM20 (3mm), Technora® (3mm), and Tungsten wire rope—for application in precision robotic mechanisms and rigging systems. The page compares key performance metrics including breaking strength, strength-to-weight ratio, thermal stability, creep characteristics, and flexibility (D/d ratio).
The findings indicate that Dyneema® SK78 offers the optimal solution for dynamic, weight-critical applications requiring aggressive routing around small radii due to its superior flexibility and high modulus. Dyneema® DM20 is identified as the preferred material for static loading scenarios where dimensional stability is paramount, effectively eliminating the creep inherent in standard HMPE fibers. Technora® is recommended for high-friction interfaces, such as capstan drives, due to its thermal resistance and grip, while Tungsten remains the specialized choice for environments requiring extreme thermal resilience or negligible elongation, provided the mechanism allows for larger bend radii (~20:1) to mitigate metal fatigue. Ultimate material selection is contingent on balancing the specific requirements of bend radius, thermal environment, and long-term calibration stability.
| Feature | Liros D-Pro 1mm (SK78) | Liros D-Pro 3mm (SK78) | Liros D-Pro Static 3mm (DM20) | Cortland Technora 3mm | Sava Tungsten (19×19 Commercial) |
| Material | Coated Dyneema® SK78 | Coated Dyneema® SK78 | Dyneema® DM20 | Technora® (Aramid) | Tungsten (Bare) |
| Diameter | 1.0 mm | 3.0 mm | 3.0 mm | 3.0 mm (1/8″) | ~ 1mm (0.35″) |
| Breaking Strength | ~195 kg (195 daN) | ~950 kg (950 daN) | ~900 kg (900 daN) | ~1,143 kg (2,520 lbs) | ~104.33 kg (230 lbs) |
| Flexibility | Extremely High | High | High | Medium-High | Low (vs. Textile) / Super (vs. Steel) |
| Min Bend (D/d) | ~5:1 (Aggressive) 8:1 (Standard) | ~8:1 (Standard) | ~8:1 (Standard) | ~10:1 (Fatigue Sensitive) | ~18:1 to 24:1 (Avoid Metal Fatigue) |
| Weight | 0.9 g/m | 4.6 g/m | 4.7 g/m | ~8.9 g/m | Very Heavy (~19 g/cm³) |
| Stretch (Elastic) | < 1% (Working Load) | < 1% (Working Load) | < 1% (Extremely Low) | Very Low | Extremely Low (High Modulus) |
| Creep (Plastic) | Low | Low | Zero Creep | Zero Creep | Zero Creep |
| Heat Limit | Low (Melts ~150°C) | Low (Melts ~150°C) | Low (Melts ~150°C) | High (Decomp. 500°C) | Extreme (Melts ~3422°C) |
| Abrasion/Friction | High Slickness (Low Friction) | High Slickness (Low Friction) | High Slickness (Low Friction) | High Grip (Good for Capstans) | Abrasive to pulleys |
| Construction | 12-strand Braid | 12-strand Braid | 12-strand Braid | 12-strand Braid | 19×19 Wire Rope (361 wires) |
Engineering Recommendations based on Robotics Context
Given that if you are dealing with humanoid mechanisms and end-effectors, here is how these specific cables fit into those subsystems:
1. End-Effectors (Fingers & Hands)
- Best Choice: Liros D-Pro 1mm (SK78) or Sava Tungsten.
- Why SK78 (1mm): Perfect for tendon-driven fingers. It is thin enough to route through finger joints, flexible enough (D/d ~5:1) to wrap around tiny localized pulleys (5mm diameter), and strong enough (195kg) to handle high grasp forces without breaking.
- Why Tungsten: If you require absolute zero stretch for precise position control (haptics) and have space for slightly larger pulleys (18mm+) in the palm/forearm, Tungsten offers the highest precision. However, routing it through tight finger joints is difficult due to the bending radius requirements.
2. Limbs & Transmission (Arms/Legs)
- Best Choice: Liros D-Pro Static (DM20).
- Why: In larger limbs, “Creep” is the enemy of calibration. Standard Dyneema (SK78) will slowly elongate under constant load (standing weight), requiring you to frequently re-calibrate your encoders or tighten turnbuckles. DM20 solves this; it is “set and forget.”
3. Capstan Drives & Winches
- Best Choice: Cortland Technora.
- Why: Dyneema is inherently self-lubricating and slippery. If you are using a capstan drive (wrapping cable around a motor shaft to drive a joint), Dyneema will often slip. Technora has a higher coefficient of friction and resists heat generated by friction slippage, making it the superior choice for high-torque wrapping applications.
4. High-Heat Environments
- Best Choice: Sava Tungsten.
- Why: If the cable must pass near hot motors, electronics that run hot, or in environments where braking heat is an issue, Tungsten is the only fail-safe. All synthetic options listed will lose structural integrity rapidly above 100°C.
Leave a comment